“What a Fool Believes,” released in 1979, stands as a quintessential example of the Doobie Brothers’ evolution from blues-rock pioneers to purveyors of sophisticated, chart-topping soft rock. The Doobie Brothers, originally formed in 1970, had already carved a significant space in the music scene with hits like “Listen to the Music” and “Long Train Runnin’.” However, the addition of Michael McDonald, with his distinctive soulful vocals and songwriting prowess, ushered in a new era for the band. They transitioned from their biker-gang associated roots towards a more polished and commercially successful sound.
“What a Fool Believes” is a prime example of this transformation. Co-written by McDonald and Kenny Loggins, the song explores the delusion of unrequited love. The lyrics depict a man clinging to the belief that a past acquaintance shares the same romantic feelings he holds, despite clear evidence to the contrary. He interprets simple kindnesses and casual interactions as signs of deeper affection, blinding himself to the reality of the situation. It’s a poignant portrayal of self-deception and the human tendency to interpret events through the lens of one’s own desires.
The song’s impact was immediate and profound. It topped the Billboard Hot 100 chart, earning the Doobie Brothers a Grammy Award for Song of the Year in 1980. Audiences resonated deeply with the song’s relatable themes and its sophisticated, yet accessible, musical arrangement. Critics praised the song’s lyrical maturity and McDonald’s heartfelt vocal performance. Even today, “What a Fool Believes” remains a staple on classic rock and soft rock radio stations, continuing to evoke feelings of bittersweet nostalgia and reminding listeners of the pitfalls of clinging to unrealistic hopes. Its enduring popularity speaks to the timeless nature of its message and the masterful craftsmanship of the Doobie Brothers.
