“What a Fool Believes,” released in 1979, remains one of the defining tracks of The Doobie Brothers’ transition into a smoother, more commercially-focused sound. The Doobie Brothers, originally known for their hard-rocking, blues-tinged sound with dual lead guitars, evolved significantly over their career. Founded in 1970 in San Jose, California, the band saw several lineup changes, most notably with the addition of Michael McDonald, whose soulful vocals and songwriting prowess heavily influenced their later work. They’ve sold over 40 million albums worldwide and were inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 2020, solidifying their place as rock legends.
“What a Fool Believes” exemplifies this shift. The song, co-written by Michael McDonald and Kenny Loggins, explores the poignant theme of unrequited love and self-deception. It portrays a man clinging to the belief that a past encounter held more significance than it actually did. He interprets casual interactions as signs of deeper affection, blinding himself to the reality that the woman has moved on. The lyrics poignantly capture the universal experience of misinterpreting signals and constructing narratives that protect our feelings, even when those narratives are based on wishful thinking.
The song resonated deeply with audiences, topping the Billboard Hot 100 chart and winning a Grammy Award for Song of the Year in 1980. Its sophisticated blend of pop, rock, and soul, coupled with McDonald’s distinctive vocals, proved a winning formula. While some longtime fans initially lamented the change in direction from their earlier, grittier sound, “What a Fool Believes” undeniably broadened their appeal and solidified their status as a mainstream success. Its enduring popularity is a testament to its relatable theme and masterful craftsmanship, continuing to evoke emotions and spark reflection about the complexities of love and perception.
